The Complete History of BMI: From Quetelet to Modern Medicine (1832-2026)
The body mass index dates from 1832, when Adolphe Quetelet described it; Ancel Keys gave it its name in 1972 (Eknoyan, 2008). Its history explains what it was built to measure and where it stops.
- Key Takeaways
- Adolphe Quetelet: The Father of BMI
- Original Purpose: Populations, Not Individuals
- Insurance Weight Tables
- Ancel Keys and the Term "BMI" (1972)
- NIH and the 1998 Cut-Offs
- WHO Global Standardization
- Modern Critiques and Limitations
- Proposed Alternatives to BMI
- Where BMI Stands Now
- Frequently Asked Questions
- 1832: Belgian mathematician Adolphe Quetelet described the index, weight divided by height squared, later known as the Quetelet index (Eknoyan, 2008)
- Original purpose: Quetelet was describing the “average man”, not measuring obesity (Eknoyan, 2008)
- 1972: Ancel Keys and colleagues named it the body mass index (Keys et al., 1972)
- 1985: an NIH consensus conference on obesity recommended wider use of BMI (NIH, 1985)
- 1995: WHO graded adult thinness by BMI (WHO, 1995); its 2000 report set the obesity classes I to III (WHO, 2000)
- 1998: NIH clinical guidelines set the overweight cutoff at a BMI of 25 (NHLBI, 1998)
- Why it stuck: Keys and colleagues preferred it for the simple calculation and because it applies to all populations at all times (Keys et al., 1972)
- Calculate yours: Use our free BMI calculator to check where you stand
BMI History Timeline
Adolphe Quetelet: The Father of BMI
The story of BMI begins in mathematics and astronomy. Adolphe Quetelet (1796–1874) was a Belgian mathematician, astronomer and statistician, born in Ghent, who applied probability to human physical characteristics and social aptitudes; he is considered a founder of the social sciences (Eknoyan, 2008).
Quetelet's interest in human measurements arose from his pioneering work in what he called "social physics" — the application of statistical methods to understand human society. He was fascinated by the concept of l'homme moyen, or "the average man," seeking to define the statistical characteristics that defined typical human beings.
"If man increased equally in all dimensions, his weight at different ages would be as the cube of his height. Now, this is not what we really observe." Adolphe Quetelet, A Treatise on Man and the Development of His Faculties (English edition, 1842), as quoted by Wells (2014)
The Birth of the Quetelet Index (1832)
Weight does not grow as the cube of height, as it would if people grew equally in all dimensions. Quetelet’s observation that “the weight increases as the square of the height” became the Quetelet index, described in 1832 (Eknoyan, 2008):
The Quetelet Index (1832)
Weight (kg) ÷ Height² (m)
Quetelet set out his work on the “average man” in his 1835 book Sur l'homme et le développement de ses facultés (Eknoyan, 2008), published in English in 1842 as A Treatise on Man and the Development of His Faculties (Wells, 2014).
Original Purpose: Populations, Not Individuals
Quetelet wasn’t measuring obesity. In developing his index, Eknoyan writes, his concern was defining the characteristics of “normal man” and fitting the distribution around the norm (Eknoyan, 2008).
The search for a practical index of relative weight began after life insurers reported higher death rates among overweight policyholders, and it ended after World War II, when epidemiologists studying heart disease found the Quetelet index the best of them; Keys named it the body mass index in 1972 (Eknoyan, 2008).
Insurance Weight Tables
Metropolitan Life Insurance Tables
Louis Dublin, a statistician and vice president of the Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, led the first tables of normal weights for height; the weights were later split by small, medium and large frames and called “ideal”, then “desirable” (Eknoyan, 2008). The company’s 1959 tables drew on more than 4 million adults, mostly men, insured from 1935 to 1953, and the frame size, judged by elbow width, was never validated (Nuttall, 2015).
Keys and colleagues later preferred the body mass index to percentage of average weight for the simplicity of the calculation and because it applies to all populations at all times (Keys et al., 1972).
Ancel Keys and the Birth of "Body Mass Index" (1972)
The American physiologist Ancel Keys (1904–2004) renamed the Quetelet index (Eknoyan, 2008). In 1972, Keys and his colleagues published “Indices of relative weight and obesity” in the Journal of Chronic Diseases (Keys et al., 1972).
The 1972 Study
Keys and colleagues analysed 7,424 men in 12 cohorts in five countries (the United States, Finland, Italy, South Africa and Japan) and compared these indices (Keys et al., 1972):
| Index | Formula | What Keys and colleagues found |
|---|---|---|
| Percentage of average weight | W as a % of the average W at that height | Unlike BMI, doesn’t apply to all populations at all times |
| Weight/Height | W/H | Slightly worse than W/H² |
| Weight/Height² (BMI) | W/H² | Slightly better than W/H |
| Ponderal index | ∛W / H | The poorest of the indices |
Source: Keys et al., 1972 (abstract).
The two tests were correlation with height, where lower is better, and with body fatness, measured by skinfolds and, in 180 men, body density, where higher is better (Keys et al., 1972).
"The body mass index seems preferable over other indices of relative weight on these grounds as well as on the simplicity of the calculation and, in contrast to percentage of average weight, the applicability to all populations at all times." Keys et al., Journal of Chronic Diseases (1972)
The paper named the ratio: “the ratio of weight to height squared, here termed the body mass index” (Keys et al., 1972).
What Keys Did and Didn’t Claim
Keys and colleagues judged BMI only slightly better than weight divided by height. And body composition could be measured accurately in large samples only after BMI was already established as the main obesity index (Wells, 2014).
NIH and the 1998 Cut-Offs
Two NIH steps set out how BMI was to be used in the United States.
1985: An NIH Consensus Conference
In February 1985, an NIH consensus conference on the health implications of obesity recommended wider use of BMI, and its summary gave reference tables of BMI values (NIH, 1985). Its panel strongly advised treatment for adults with a BMI above 27.8 for men or 27.3 for women.
1998: The Cut-Offs Used Today
NIH’s 1998 clinical guidelines set overweight at a BMI of 25 to 29.9 and obesity at 30 or more (NHLBI, 1998). US surveys had counted adults as overweight from a BMI of 27.8 for men and 27.3 for women, so adults between 25 and those values moved into the overweight group (NHLBI, 1998). By the new definitions, 54.9% of US adults were overweight or obese in NHANES III: 32.6% overweight and 22.3% with obesity (NHLBI Evidence Report, 1998).
WHO Global Standardization
WHO’s 1995 report on anthropometry graded adult thinness by BMI: below 18.5, below 17 and below 16 (WHO, 1995). Its 2000 report on obesity set out classes I (30 to 34.9), II (35 to 39.9) and III (40 or more) and concluded that a coherent system based on BMI should be adopted internationally (WHO, 2000).
WHO’s adult categories run from underweight (below 18.5) to class III obesity (40 and above); our BMI categories guide explains each one.
Asian BMI Cutoffs (2004)
A WHO expert consultation kept the international cut-offs but found that the share of Asian people at high risk of type 2 diabetes and cardiovascular disease is substantial below the overweight cut-off of 25, and it named public health action points at a BMI of 23.0, 27.5, 32.5 and 37.5 (WHO Expert Consultation, 2004).
Modern Critiques and Limitations of BMI
CDC calls BMI “a quick, low-cost, and reliable screening measure”, but it does not directly measure body fat (CDC). Our BMI limitations guide goes through the evidence.
Core Limitations
Doesn't Distinguish Fat from Muscle
BMI “does not distinguish between fat, muscle, and bone mass” (CDC). NICE advises interpreting it with caution in adults with high muscle mass (NICE NG246).
Ignores Fat Distribution
BMI says nothing about where fat sits. NIH’s 1998 guidelines add waist circumference because excess abdominal fat is an independent risk factor for disease (NHLBI, 1998).
Height Bias
Trefethen argues that dividing by height squared makes short people think they are thinner, and tall people fatter, than they are (Trefethen); it is why he proposed his “New BMI”.
Age Not Considered
CDC’s adult categories apply regardless of age (CDC), but body fat at the same BMI rises with age: at a BMI of 25, Gallagher and colleagues predicted 20% body fat for African American and white men aged 20 to 39 and 25% at 60 to 79 (Gallagher et al., 2000, Table 4). NICE advises interpreting BMI with caution in people aged 65 and over (NICE NG246).
Sex Differences Ignored
Women carry more body fat than men at the same BMI. In CDC’s 2011–2018 body scans of adults aged 20 to 59 with a BMI of 18.5 to 24.9, the median body fat was 33.4% for women and 22.1% for men (our body fat percentage chart uses the same scans).
Ethnic Variation
NICE uses lower thresholds for adults of South Asian, Chinese, other Asian, Middle Eastern, Black African or African-Caribbean family background, whose cardiometabolic risk occurs at a lower BMI: overweight from 23 and obesity from 27.5 (NICE NG246).
For individuals, CDC says BMI should be considered with other factors, such as blood pressure and cholesterol levels (CDC).
BMI and Survival After 65
In a meta-analysis of 197,940 people aged 65 and over, compared with a BMI of 23 to 23.9, the risk of death was higher below 23 and began to rise above 33 (Winter et al., 2014).
Proposed Alternatives to BMI
The alternatives come in two kinds: another formula from weight and height, and measures that look at the waist or at fat itself.
Trefethen's "New BMI" (2013)
Oxford mathematician Nick Trefethen proposed a modified formula that uses height to the power of 2.5 instead of 2:
Trefethen's New BMI Formula
New BMI = 1.3 × weight (kg) ÷ height (m)2.5
Trefethen argues that the 2.5 power fits the shapes of short and tall people better than the square, which makes short people think they are thinner, and tall people fatter, than they are; he adds that his formula is not based on epidemiological studies (Trefethen). Try it with our New BMI calculator.
Other Measures
Our BMI limitations guide compares the measures used beside BMI, from waist circumference to DXA scans, each with its source, and the waist-to-height ratio calculator works out one of them.
Where BMI Stands Now
Multi-Metric Approaches
Guidelines pair BMI with other measures. NIH’s 1998 guidelines read waist circumference alongside BMI in adults with a BMI of 25 to 34.9 (NHLBI, 1998), and NICE now uses waist-to-height ratio (NICE NG246).
Home Body Fat Devices
Body fat scales and hand-held devices estimate body fat by bioelectrical impedance. In a study of 437 college students, a hand-held impedance device was 4.9 points off a DXA scan on average (Burns et al., 2019); our guide on how to measure body fat compares the methods.
Will BMI Be Replaced?
Not so far: WHO and CDC still define adult overweight and obesity by BMI (WHO; CDC).
Frequently Asked Questions About BMI History
Belgian mathematician, astronomer and statistician Adolphe Quetelet described the index in 1832, and it became known as the Quetelet index. Ancel Keys and colleagues named it the body mass index in a 1972 paper in the Journal of Chronic Diseases, 140 years later. So the formula is nearly 200 years old and the name BMI just over 50.
Quetelet was studying the average man (l'homme moyen): he applied probability to human physical characteristics and social aptitudes. In developing his index he had no interest in obesity; his concern was the characteristics of normal man and the distribution around the norm (Eknoyan, 2008).
In stages. In 1985 an NIH consensus conference recommended wider use of BMI (NIH, 1985). NIH’s 1998 guidelines then set overweight at a BMI of 25 to 29.9 and obesity at 30 or more (NHLBI, 1998). WHO’s 2000 report set the obesity classes used today (WHO, 2000). Earlier weight standards came from insurers, such as Metropolitan Life’s 1959 tables of desirable weights (Nuttall, 2015).
Keys and colleagues preferred it in 1972 for the simple calculation and because, unlike percentage of average weight, it applies to all populations at all times (Keys et al., 1972). CDC calls it “a quick, low-cost, and reliable screening measure” and says that for individuals it should be considered with other factors, such as blood pressure and cholesterol levels (CDC). Guidelines pair it with a waist measure: NIH’s 1998 guidelines with waist circumference, NICE with the waist-to-height ratio (NHLBI, 1998; NICE NG246).
In 2013, Oxford mathematician Nick Trefethen proposed a modified formula: New BMI = 1.3 × weight (kg) / height (m)^2.5. He argues that the standard BMI makes short people think they are thinner, and tall people fatter, than they are; he also writes that his formula is not based on epidemiological studies and may not be an improvement (Trefethen). Try our New BMI calculator to see how your results compare.
No. Quetelet was a mathematician, astronomer and statistician studying the average man, and in developing his index he had no interest in obesity (Eknoyan, 2008). Medical use came after World War II, when heart disease epidemiology took up the Quetelet index, which Keys named the body mass index in 1972.
Related Guides
This article is for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. BMI is a screening tool, not a diagnostic measure. If you’re concerned about your weight, CDC says to talk with your health care provider (CDC).
- Quetelet, A. (1835). Sur l'homme et le développement de ses facultés. Paris: Bachelier.
- Keys, A., et al. (1972). "Indices of relative weight and obesity." Journal of Chronic Diseases, 25(6-7), 329-343.
- WHO Expert Committee. (1995). Physical status: the use and interpretation of anthropometry. WHO Technical Report Series 854.
- NIH. (1998). Clinical Guidelines on the Identification, Evaluation, and Treatment of Overweight and Obesity in Adults.
- WHO Expert Consultation. (2004). "Appropriate body-mass index for Asian populations." The Lancet, 363(9403), 157-163.
- WHO: Obesity and Overweight Fact Sheet
- CDC: About BMI
- Eknoyan G. (2008). Adolphe Quetelet (1796–1874): the average man and indices of obesity. Nephrology Dialysis Transplantation, 23(1), 47-51.
- Nuttall FQ. (2015). Body Mass Index: Obesity, BMI, and Health: A Critical Review. Nutrition Today, 50(3), 117-128.
- NIH Consensus Development Conference. (1985). Health implications of obesity. International Journal of Obesity, 9(3), 155-170.
- Winter JE, et al. (2014). BMI and all-cause mortality in older adults: a meta-analysis. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 99(4), 875-890.