New BMI Calculator (Trefethen Formula)

See your BMI with the 2013 formula from Oxford professor Nick Trefethen, next to the traditional one.

A mathematician’s proposal, not a medical standard: CDC still calculates BMI with height squared. Method and sources

—
—
—
Under
Healthy
Over
Class 1
Class 2+
1518.525303540

New BMI and traditional BMI

New BMI
—
Traditional BMI
—
Difference
—
Category
—

Healthy weight at your height

CDC’s healthy range, a traditional BMI of 18.5 to 24.9.

Lowest healthy weight
—
Highest healthy weight
—

—

Key takeaways

New BMI is Nick Trefethen’s 2013 alternative to the traditional formula, proposed while he was a professor at the University of Oxford: 1.3 × kg ÷ m2.5, or 5734 × lb ÷ in2.5. It matches traditional BMI at about 5′6.5″ (1.69 m), reads higher if you are shorter and lower if you are taller.

  • The gap depends on height alone: New BMI is 5.3% higher than traditional BMI at 5′0″ and 3.9% lower at 6′0″, whatever you weigh.
  • A traditional BMI of 25.0 becomes 26.3 at 5′0″ and 24.0 at 6′0″.
  • Trefethen says his formula is “not based on epidemiological studies” and may not be an improvement.
  • CDC’s formula uses height squared and its cut-offs are set on that number, so use traditional BMI for anything medical.

Medical disclaimer: This calculator gives estimates for information only. BMI is a screening measure, not a diagnosis. Ask a healthcare professional for medical advice.

The two formulas

Traditional BMI and New BMI
FormulaUS unitsMetric
Traditional BMIlb ÷ in² × 703kg ÷ m²
New BMI5734 × lb ÷ in2.51.3 × kg ÷ m2.5

The constants keep the reading unchanged at what Trefethen calls “average height, which I take to be about 66.5 inches, i.e., 1.69 meters”. The square root of 1.69 is 1.3, so at that height New BMI and traditional BMI are the same number.

Divide one formula by the other and weight cancels: New BMI = traditional BMI × 1.3 ÷ √height (m). Below 1.69 m that factor is above 1, so New BMI comes out higher; above 1.69 m it is below 1, so it comes out lower.

How much New BMI changes your number

The figure shows the gap in points at 154 lb (70 kg); the table under it gives the gap as a percentage of traditional BMI.

How much New BMI differs from traditional BMI at each height, at 154 lb (70 kg)New BMI minus traditional BMI at 154 lb (70 kg), from 4′7.1″ to 6′6.7″ (1.40 to 2.00 m): 3.5 points higher at 4′7.1″, 1.6 higher at 5′0″ (1.52 m), the same at 5′6.5″ (1.69 m), 0.8 lower at 6′0″ (1.83 m) and 1.4 lower at 6′6.7″. Our calculation from the two formulas.New BMI minus traditional BMI at 154 lb (70 kg)−2−10+1+2+3+44′8″1.42 m5′0″1.52 m5′4″1.63 m5′8″1.73 m6′0″1.83 m6′4″1.93 m5′0″ (1.52 m): New BMI 1.6 points higher at 154 lb+1.6 at 5′0″6′0″ (1.83 m): New BMI 0.8 points lower at 154 lb−0.8 at 6′0″Same at 5′6.5″ (1.69 m)Same at 5′6.5″ (1.69 m)
New BMI minus traditional BMI at 154 lb (70 kg), from 4′7.1″ to 6′6.7″ (1.40 to 2.00 m): higher below 5′6.5″, lower above it. Our calculation.
New BMI against traditional BMI, by height
HeightChange25.0 becomes
5′0″1.52 m+5.3%26.3
5′4″1.63 m+2.0%25.5
5′6.5″1.69 m0.0%25.0
5′8″1.73 m−1.1%24.7
5′10″1.78 m−2.5%24.4
6′0″1.83 m−3.9%24.0
6′4″1.93 m−6.4%23.4

Weight doesn’t change these percentages, only the number of points they come to, which is why the gap grows with weight in the next table.

Trefethen’s rough guide is that “each person 6 feet tall would lose a point from their BMI reading” and “each person 5 feet tall would gain a point”. At a traditional BMI of 25.0 the formula gives 1.0 point less at 6′0″ and 1.3 points more at 5′0″.

Traditional and New BMI side by side

Each row is what the calculator above prints for that height and weight. The difference subtracts the two rounded numbers, as the calculator does.

Traditional and New BMI at five heights and four weights
WeightTraditionalNew BMIDifference
5′0″ (152.4 cm)
120 lb54.4 kg23.424.7+1.3
150 lb†68.0 kg29.330.8+1.5
180 lb81.6 kg35.237.0+1.8
210 lb95.3 kg41.043.2+2.2
5′4″ (162.6 cm)
120 lb54.4 kg20.621.0+0.4
150 lb68.0 kg25.726.3+0.6
180 lb81.6 kg30.931.5+0.6
210 lb95.3 kg36.036.8+0.8
5′8″ (172.7 cm)
120 lb54.4 kg18.218.0−0.2
150 lb68.0 kg22.822.6−0.2
180 lb81.6 kg27.427.1−0.3
210 lb95.3 kg31.931.6−0.3
6′0″ (182.9 cm)
120 lb†54.4 kg16.315.6−0.7
150 lb68.0 kg20.319.6−0.7
180 lb81.6 kg24.423.5−0.9
210 lb95.3 kg28.527.4−1.1
6′4″ (193.0 cm)
120 lb54.4 kg14.613.7−0.9
150 lb68.0 kg18.317.1−1.2
180 lb81.6 kg21.920.5−1.4
210 lb†95.3 kg25.623.9−1.7

† The category changes with New BMI: at 5′0″ and 150 lb from Overweight to Class 1 obesity, at 6′4″ and 210 lb from Overweight to Healthy weight, and at 6′0″ and 120 lb from Moderate thinness to Severe thinness (the calculator’s names for a BMI of 16 to 16.9 and under 16).

The widest gaps sit at the ends: +2.2 at 5′0″ and 210 lb, −1.7 at 6′4″ and 210 lb. At 5′8″, close to the 5′6.5″ crossover, the two formulas stay within 0.3 of each other at every weight shown.

Two worked examples

5′2″ and 150 lb (157.5 cm, 68.0 kg)

Traditional BMI: 27.4, Overweight
150 × 703 ÷ 62² = 27.4. In metric, 68.04 ÷ 1.5748² gives the same 27.4.
New BMI: 28.4, Overweight
5734 × 150 ÷ 622.5 = 28.4. In metric, 1.3 × 68.04 ÷ 1.57482.5 = 28.4.
Difference: +1.0
28.4 − 27.4. Both numbers are overweight, so the category stays the same.

6′2″ and 150 lb (188.0 cm, 68.0 kg)

Traditional BMI: 19.3, Healthy weight
150 × 703 ÷ 74² = 19.3. In metric, 68.04 ÷ 1.8796² gives the same 19.3.
New BMI: 18.3, Underweight
5734 × 150 ÷ 742.5 = 18.3. In metric, 1.3 × 68.04 ÷ 1.87962.5 = 18.3.
Difference: −1.0
18.3 − 19.3. The category changes from Healthy weight to Underweight: New BMI drops below CDC’s 18.5 cut-off. CDC set that cut-off on traditional BMI, and on CDC’s scale this person, at 19.3, is a healthy weight.

Why Trefethen proposed it

In a letter to The Economist published on 5 January 2013, signed as professor of numerical analysis at the University of Oxford, Nick Trefethen called BMI “a bizarre measure”. He wrote: “We live in a three-dimensional world, yet the BMI is defined as weight divided by height squared.” His conclusion was that “millions of short people think they are thinner than they are, and millions of tall people think they are fatter.”

The formula is on his Oxford page, where he explains the exponent: “I propose that a better approximation to the actual sizes and shapes of healthy bodies might be given by an exponent of 2.5.”

On the same page he sets out the limits of his proposal. “I am an applied mathematician, not a doctor or an epidemiologist,” he writes, and the new formulas are “not based on epidemiological studies” and may not be an improvement. He points to a 2007 paper by Heymsfield and colleagues in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition that supports the exponent 2.

Which number to use

For anything medical, use traditional BMI. CDC calculates BMI as weight (kg) ÷ height (m)², or weight (lb) ÷ height (in)² × 703, and sets its adult categories on that number: under 18.5 underweight, 18.5 to 24.9 healthy weight, 25 to 29.9 overweight and 30 or more obesity. WHO uses the same two lines for adults: overweight at a BMI of 25 or more, obesity at 30 or more.

New BMI is worth a second look if you are very short or very tall, where the formulas part most: 5.3% higher at 5′0″, 6.4% lower at 6′4″. The calculator applies CDC’s cut-offs to both numbers so you can compare them.

Neither formula can separate muscle from fat. CDC notes that “BMI does not distinguish between fat, muscle, and bone mass”, and New BMI works from the same height and weight. The body fat calculator estimates body fat with a tape measure or calipers, and body fat vs BMI covers how the two measures differ.

Frequently asked questions

New BMI = 5734 × weight (lb) ÷ height (in) to the power 2.5, or 1.3 × weight (kg) ÷ height (m) to the power 2.5. Nick Trefethen set it out in 2013 on his University of Oxford page as an alternative to the traditional formula, which divides by height squared. The two constants make both formulas give the same reading at about 5′6.5″ (1.69 m).

Nick Trefethen, who signed his letter to The Economist of 5 January 2013 as professor of numerical analysis at the University of Oxford. The letter called BMI “a bizarre measure”; the formula itself is on his Oxford page. He describes himself there as “an applied mathematician, not a doctor or an epidemiologist.”

That is the name many people use when they search for New BMI, the formula Nick Trefethen published in 2013 while he was a professor at the University of Oxford. This calculator applies his formula, which is on his Oxford page. It is his own proposal, not a medical standard, and CDC still uses the traditional formula.

It divides weight by height to the power 2.5 instead of height squared, then multiplies by 1.3. Weight cancels out when you compare the two: New BMI = traditional BMI × 1.3 ÷ √height (m). So the gap depends on height alone, from 5.3% higher at 5′0″ to 3.9% lower at 6′0″ (our calculation).

Trefethen doesn’t claim that. He writes that his formulas are “not based on epidemiological studies” and may not be an improvement, and he points to a 2007 paper by Heymsfield and colleagues in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition that supports the exponent 2. CDC’s adult categories are set on traditional BMI.

Use traditional BMI for anything medical, since CDC’s adult categories are set on it. New BMI is a second look if you are very short or very tall, where the two differ most: 5.3% higher at 5′0″ and 6.4% lower at 6′4″ (our calculation). Neither formula can tell muscle from fat.

Only when your BMI is close to a cut-off. At 5′0″ and 150 lb, traditional BMI is 29.3 (Overweight) and New BMI 30.8 (Class 1 obesity); at 6′4″ and 210 lb, 25.6 (Overweight) becomes 23.9 (Healthy weight). At 5′8″ the two stay within 0.3 of each other from 120 to 210 lb. The calculator shows both categories for your numbers.

CDC uses traditional BMI: weight (kg) ÷ height (m)², or weight (lb) ÷ height (in)² × 703. WHO defines adult overweight as a BMI of 25 or more and obesity as 30 or more, the same lines as CDC’s categories. The calculator puts both numbers on CDC’s scale.

Sources and method

Written by Marko Visic, MPharm. “Our calculation” means we worked the figure out from the two formulas with the method below.

Method. Every number in the tables, the figure and the examples is our calculation with the calculator’s own arithmetic: traditional BMI = lb ÷ in² × 703 (kg ÷ m² for metric entries) and New BMI = 1.3 × kg ÷ m2.5, with kg = lb ÷ 2.20462 and m = in × 0.0254. Each BMI is rounded once to one decimal, halves up, and its category comes from that rounded value. The difference subtracts the two rounded values, so it matches what the calculator prints. The percentages are 1.3 ÷ √height (m) − 1, rounded to 0.1%. The figure plots the unrounded difference at 70 kg every 0.01 m from 1.40 to 2.00 m. Trefethen’s 5734 rounds the US-unit constant, so working in pounds and inches with it can move the last decimal near a rounding edge; both worked examples give the same result either way.

Related calculators and guides